TBD | Back To School… Without Phones
Digest
This episode of the Tedtech podcast delves into the controversial topic of cell phone bans in schools. The discussion begins with Russell Shaw, head of school at Georgetown Day School, who shares his decision to ban cell phones at his school, citing concerns about student mental health and the need for increased human connection. Laura Mechler, an education reporter for the Washington Post, then provides a broader perspective on the national trend of school cell phone bans, highlighting the diverse approaches schools are taking and the reasons behind this movement. The podcast explores the perspectives of parents, some of whom are relieved by the restrictions while others express concerns about communication and safety. The conversation then shifts to the impact of the pandemic on technology use in schools, examining how schools are navigating the increased reliance on technology while addressing its potential downsides. The episode also delves into the complex relationship between technology and mental health, questioning whether phone bans are a sufficient solution and emphasizing the need for comprehensive mental health support in schools. Mechler shares her personal experiences with setting technology limits for her own children, highlighting the challenges and the importance of establishing boundaries early on. The episode concludes with a call to action for listeners to support Slate Plus and a reminder of the importance of engaging in conversations about technology and its impact on education and mental health.
Outlines
The Cell Phone Ban Movement in Schools
This episode explores the growing movement to ban cell phones in schools, examining the reasons behind it, the various approaches schools are taking, and the potential benefits and drawbacks for students, parents, and educators.
School Cell Phone Bans: A National Trend
This chapter discusses the growing trend of school cell phone bans across the country, highlighting the various approaches schools are taking and the reasons behind this movement.
Technology, Mental Health, and the Future of Education
This chapter explores the complex relationship between technology and mental health, questioning whether phone bans are a sufficient solution and emphasizing the need for comprehensive mental health support in schools.
Conclusion and Call to Action
The episode concludes with a call to action for listeners to support Slate Plus and a reminder of the importance of engaging in conversations about technology and its impact on education and mental health.
Keywords
Cell Phone Ban
A policy implemented by schools to restrict or prohibit the use of cell phones during school hours, often aimed at improving student focus, engagement, and mental well-being.
Mental Health Crisis
A significant increase in mental health issues, particularly among adolescents, often attributed to factors like social media use, academic pressure, and societal changes.
Educational Technology
The use of technology in educational settings, encompassing tools like laptops, tablets, online learning platforms, and AI-powered applications, to enhance teaching and learning experiences.
Human Connection
The importance of face-to-face interactions and meaningful relationships in fostering social development, emotional well-being, and a sense of belonging.
Digital Tether
The constant connection and accessibility provided by smartphones, which can create a sense of dependence and anxiety for both parents and children.
Social Media Addiction
A compulsive and excessive use of social media platforms, often characterized by withdrawal symptoms, impaired functioning, and negative impacts on mental health.
Q&A
What are the main reasons behind the growing movement to ban cell phones in schools?
Schools are banning cell phones to improve student focus, reduce distractions, and address concerns about the negative impact of technology on mental health.
How are schools implementing cell phone bans, and what are the different approaches?
Schools are using various methods, from simple requests to collect phones to more restrictive policies involving locking pouches and complete phone bans during school hours.
What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of school cell phone bans?
Benefits include improved focus, reduced distractions, and potentially better mental health. Drawbacks include concerns about communication, safety, and the potential for students to miss out on positive aspects of technology.
How are schools grappling with the increased reliance on technology in the post-pandemic era?
Schools are navigating the balance between embracing technology for educational purposes and addressing its potential downsides, including distractions and negative impacts on mental health.
What are the broader implications of the cell phone ban movement for education and mental health?
The movement highlights the need for a comprehensive approach to addressing mental health concerns in schools, including providing adequate resources and support for students.
What advice do you have for parents regarding setting technology limits for their children?
It's easier to set limits early on than to try to restrict access later. Technology can be addictive, so it's important to establish boundaries and encourage healthy habits.
Show Notes
Since the pandemic, schools have been reporting that their students are more anxious and having trouble learning. How much does simply removing cell phones from the classroom address these problems?
Guests:
Laura Meckler, national education writer for the Washington Post
Russell Shaw, head of Georgetown Day School and author of “Why We’re Banning Phones at Our School” for the Atlantic.
Want more What Next TBD? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Table of contents
United States
